Stock Detective
Case file · Grade 8+

Stock Detective

Buying a stock means buying a small piece of a real business. Good investors act like detectives: they gather clues about the business before they put any money in. This notebook teaches you the clues Warren Buffett uses, one at a time, with things you can try.

Level 1 · Basics→ Level 2 · Detective→ Level 3 · Investor→ Level 4 · Game Time (soon)→ Case Files (soon)
Level 1

Basics

What a stock is and how money grows. Start here.

CHAPTER 1

What is a stock?

Imagine your friend Maya runs a lemonade business and splits it into 100 equal pieces. Each piece is called a share. If you buy 10 shares, you own 10% of the business. That means 10% of what it owns and 10% of the profit it makes.

Big companies work the same way, just with billions of shares. When people say "I bought Apple stock," they mean they bought a few of Apple's shares.

A few more words you'll see everywhere. Every company that sells shares has a short nickname called a ticker symbol. Apple's is AAPL. Nike's is NKE. Shares are bought and sold on a stock exchange, a big marketplace for shares. The two main ones in the U.S. are the NYSE (New York Stock Exchange) and the NASDAQ.

The total number of shares a company has handed out is its shares outstanding. Multiply that by the price of one share and you get its market cap: the price tag for the whole company.

Buy shares of Maya's Lemonade
You own10%
Your slice of the profit$100

A share is only worth buying if the business behind it is good. That's why the rest of this notebook is about the business, not just the price.

Level 2

Detective

Read a company's clues like a pro: what it owns, what it earns, and what it's worth.

CHAPTER 2 · Buffett's balance sheet rules

The balance sheet: what it owns vs. what it owes

A balance sheet is a snapshot of a business on one day. It lists everything the company owns and everything it owes. Its master rule always balances:

Assets = Liabilities + Shareholders' equity

Assets: what it owns (cash, supplies, equipment). Liabilities: what it owes (loans, unpaid bills). Equity: what's left for the owners.

Warren Buffett has read thousands of balance sheets. He uses 5 rules of thumb to judge one in seconds:

  1. More cash than debt. The best businesses make so much cash they don't need to borrow.
  2. Debt-to-equity below 0.8. Total liabilities ÷ shareholders' equity. A low number means the owners' money, not borrowed money, built the business.
  3. No preferred stock. Preferred stock is a mix of a loan and a share. Strong companies rarely need it.
  4. Retained earnings keep growing, especially in bad years. These are the profits the company has kept and reinvested over its life.
  5. Has treasury stock. That's the shares the company has bought back from investors. It shows the company is returning cash to owners.
Check the lemonade stand's balance sheet
Owns (assets)
Owes (liabilities)
Owners' section (equity details)
Owns $ = Owes $ + Owners' equity $

Detective tip: a "fail" means look closer. In the video, Chipotle failed the debt-to-equity rule. Its biggest liability turned out to be restaurant leases (rent it has promised to pay), and big buybacks had shrunk its equity. Once you understand why a number fails, it may not be a problem at all.
Real case: Johnson & Johnson (June 2026)
RuleClueDetective note
1 · Cash vs. debt$20.8B vs $49.0BFAIL More debt than cash. But it earns enough to pay its interest about 26 times over, so the debt isn't scary.
2 · Debt-to-equity0.58CHECK This website figure uses debt only. Buffett's rule uses all liabilities, which gives a higher number. Look it up!
3–5 · Preferred, retained earnings, treasury?HOMEWORK Find J&J's latest annual report (10-K) and look in the shareholders' equity section.
CHAPTER 3

Profit: how much of each dollar does it keep?

Revenue (also called sales) is all the money coming in. Profit is what's left after paying for everything. The profit margin tells you how many cents of every $1 in sales the business keeps.

A business that keeps 25¢ of every dollar can survive price wars and bad years much better than one that keeps 2¢.

Run the stand for a summer
Revenue
Profit
Margin (kept per $1)
Real case: Johnson & Johnson

J&J sold about $97.9B in a year and kept 21.5¢ of every dollar as profit. That's a high margin. Most stores keep under 5¢.

CHAPTER 4 Level 1 · Basics

Growth: the magic of compounding

Growth is measured as a percentage per year. Small yearly growth adds up to huge numbers over time, because each year grows on top of the last. That's called compounding.

Investors use CAGR (compound annual growth rate), the average yearly growth over several years. Buffett's very first filter is whether a business is predictable: does revenue go up year after year, or jump around?

Watch $1,000 of profit grow

Real case: Johnson & Johnson

Revenue went from $79B (2021) to $98B (latest year), rising every year. That's slow, steady and predictable growth of roughly 4–6% a year.

CHAPTER 5

The 5 life phases of a company

Every public company is in one of five phases. Knowing the phase tells you what "good" looks like, and even how to value the company. A young company losing money can be normal. An old company losing money is a warning sign.

$0 revenue profit payouts losses peak breakeven 12345
1StartupLittle revenue, losing lots of money. Very risky.
2Hyper growthRevenue takes off. Still losing money, but losses are shrinking.
3Operating leverageProfits appear because revenue grows faster than costs. Not paying owners yet.
4Capital returnA cash cow. Hands cash back to owners with dividends and buybacks.
5DeclineRevenue falling for a few years. Tries to turn around, or shrinks.
Buffett's clue: in the video's analysis of Berkshire Hathaway's portfolio, about 74% of its companies were in phase 4 and 26% in phase 5. None were in phases 1–3. Buffett sticks to businesses that already hand cash back.
Which phase is each mystery company in?
Real case: Johnson & Johnson

Phase 4. Slow steady growth, very profitable, and in the latest year it paid about $13B in dividends plus $8B buying back shares.

CHAPTER 6

The moat: what keeps competitors out?

A castle has a moat so attackers can't get in. A business with a moat has something that stops rivals from stealing its customers. Without one, high profits attract copycats who cut prices until the profits are gone.

Five common kinds: switching costs (leaving is a pain), network effects (more users make it better), scale (biggest = cheapest), brand & patents (people trust it, or the law protects it), and counter-positioning (a new way of doing business the old players can't copy without hurting themselves).

Detectives ask two questions: how wide is the moat, and is it getting wider or narrower?

Match the business to its moat
CHAPTER 7

Payouts: dividends and buybacks

Phase 4 companies make more cash than they need, so they give it back to owners in two ways:

Dividends: cash paid straight to owners, usually every 3 months. A dividend yield of 2% means you get $2 a year for every $100 of stock.

Buybacks: the company buys its own shares (these become treasury stock, Buffett's rule 5 in The balance sheet). Fewer slices means each remaining slice is a bigger piece of the pie. But if the company also hands out new shares to employees, the slice count can still go up. That's called dilution.

Pizza slice buyback
Your 1 slice (green) is now10%of the whole company
Real case: Johnson & Johnson

Dividends: about $13B a year and rising (yield about 2%). Buybacks: about $8B, but its share count still went up, so the label is "yes, but diluting."

CHAPTER 8

Price tags: multiples

A stock's price alone tells you nothing. Is $100 a share expensive? It depends on what you get. A multiple compares the price to something the company earns, so you can compare fairly.

The most famous is the P/E ratio, or price ÷ earnings (profit). A P/E of 20 means you pay $20 for each $1 the company earns per year.

What does a P/E mean?

The phase decides which multiple works. P/E only works when a company is optimized for profit (phases 4–5). Younger companies are spending to grow, so their profit is tiny or negative. For them, you move up the income statement to a number that makes sense.

Pick a phase, get the right price tag
Real case: Johnson & Johnson (phase 4, so P/E works)
MultipleJ&JMeaning
Price / Earnings (P/E)30.3×$30 for each $1 of yearly profit
Price / Free cash flow28.3×$28 for each $1 of spare cash
Price / Sales6.4×$6.40 for each $1 of yearly sales
CHAPTER 9 · Buffett's 5-step value check

What is a business really worth?

Buffett wrote that a business is worth all the cash it will hand out over its life, counted in today's money. That's its intrinsic value.

Why "today's money"? Because a dollar you get later is worth less than a dollar now. You have to wait, and you could have invested it in the meantime. So we discount future dollars.

How much is a future $100 worth today?
Worth todayAt 10%: $100 in 5 years ≈ $62 today; in 10 years ≈ $39.

Many investors turn this into a discounted cash flow (DCF) calculator: guess the future cash, discount it, add it up. But there's a twist. Charlie Munger, Buffett's partner, said at a 1996 meeting that he'd never actually seen Buffett do one. Buffett agreed and said that if the value doesn't scream out at you, it's too close to call. Try the calculator to see why.

The DCF calculator (and its trap)
"Value" per share
Price today
Price vs. value
The trap: move the growth slider from 6% to 9%. The "value" jumps a lot, from a tiny change in a guess. You can make a DCF say almost any number you want. It looks precise, but it isn't. That false precision is why Buffett prefers a simpler path.

Buffett's simpler 5 steps

  1. Is it predictable? If you can't tell where the business will be in 10 years, put it in the "too hard" pile and move on. Buffett literally has a tray on his desk for this.
  2. Is it in phase 4 (or 5)? He values businesses that already hand cash back to owners (see The 5 life phases).
  3. Use a multiple, not a complicated model. Compare the price to what the company earns (see Price tags).
  4. Pick the right multiple for the phase. For phase 4–5 companies, P/E works.
  5. Compare it to the company's own history, then adjust for quality. Is today's multiple high or low versus its usual level? Then ask whether the business deserves more or less.
Cheap or expensive vs. its own history? (Fizz Cola, a made-up company)
Step 5b: adjust for quality (each moves the fair P/E by 10%)
Cheap below
Fair P/E after quality
Expensive above

The video worked through Apple this way. Its revenue was predictable and it was clearly in phase 4, but its growth had slowed to about 2% a year while its P/E sat near 37, well above the roughly 21 of 2022. So: a great business, but not a cheap price. Great company and good investment aren't the same thing. The price matters.
Level 3

Investor

Put the clues together and close the case.

CHAPTER 10

Close the case: your decision checklist

Pick any company and rate each clue from 1 (bad) to 5 (great). The checklist won't tell you what to buy. It shows how strong your case is and which clues need more digging.

Detective scorecard
Golden rules for young investors. Under 18, you'll need a parent or guardian to open a custodial account. Only invest money you won't need for years. Own several companies, not just one, or a simple index fund that owns hundreds. Expect prices to drop sometimes. That's normal. And never buy something just because it's popular online.
DETECTIVE'S DICTIONARY

Words to know

Share / stock
A small piece of ownership in a company.
Ticker symbol
A company's short stock-market nickname, like AAPL for Apple or KO for Coca-Cola.
Stock exchange
A marketplace where people buy and sell shares. The NYSE and the NASDAQ are the two biggest in the U.S.
Shares outstanding
The total number of shares a company has handed out to its owners.
Market cap
Price of one share × shares outstanding. The price tag for the whole company.
Revenue
All the money a business brings in from sales.
Profit (earnings)
What's left after paying all the costs.
Margin
Profit as a percent of revenue: cents kept per $1 of sales.
Balance sheet
A snapshot of everything a company owns and owes on one day.
Assets
Everything the business owns.
Liabilities
Everything the business owes.
Shareholders' equity
Assets minus liabilities: the owners' part.
Debt-to-equity
Total liabilities ÷ equity. Buffett likes it below 0.8.
Preferred stock
A mix of a loan and a share. Strong companies rarely need it.
Retained earnings
All the profit a company has kept over its life instead of paying it out.
Treasury stock
Shares a company has bought back from investors.
Free cash flow
Cash left over after running and maintaining the business.
CAGR
Average yearly growth over several years, with compounding.
Moat
An advantage that protects a business from competitors.
Dividend
Cash a company pays to its owners.
Buyback
A company buying its own shares so each remaining share owns more.
Dilution
New shares being created, so each share owns less.
Multiple
Price compared with something the company earns, like P/E or P/S.
P/E ratio
Price ÷ yearly profit. How many dollars you pay for $1 of yearly profit.
Intrinsic value
What a business is worth based on all its future cash, in today's money.
Discounting
Shrinking future dollars into today's dollars, because money later is worth less.
DCF
Discounted cash flow: a calculator that adds up discounted future cash. Very sensitive to guesses.
Too-hard pile
Buffett's name for businesses too unpredictable to value. Skip them.